By the Book

Aisling's picture

Yes, I watch children's shows. I'm a babysitter. Get over it.

By the book. It's an odd phrase. It means following instructions, or doing things the way they were mean to be done. It's not a very common phrase. So when I heard it the other day, it caught my attention.

I was watching some children and a nearby television was on, tuned to a children's show channel. A show called “Wow Wow Wubzy” was on and at the end of the episode a “moral of the story” song started. It was called, “By the Book”.

“It's good to do things,

The proper way.

But if things go wrong,

That's okay.

If it's not right,

Don't be uptight.

It doesn't have to be by the book.”

The song bothered me slightly at the time. At first, it seems like an alright message to teach children. But then, if you think about it, it applies to a lot more than the song implies. Yeah, a tea party may go wrong, or you have to invent a new kind of game with the pieces you have. But there are other rules out there. And not all of them are flexible.

Further along in the song, it says:

“If the recipe calls for juddleberry(?) jam,

But all you have is polka-dot ham,

It's not a waste,

Enjoy the taste,

Cause it doesn't have to be by the book.”

The cartoon that goes along with it then shows the characters eating a lovely cake. But I work in the kitchen and I happen to know that you can't make cake with ham. Not just that it won't taste good, it simply, physically, won't work.

Well, so what. By the time the kids can work in the kitchen, they know better.

But, as I said before, the song can be applied to life in general.

There's only one way to cross the street, and that's by the book.

Amusingly, a couple of days after I saw this song, on the same channel, I saw another song for a different show. The show is called LazyTown and the phrase “by the book” caught my attention again.

“It's a piece of cake to bake a pretty cake.

If the way is hazy,

You gotta do the cooking by the book.

You know you can't be lazy.

Never use a messy recipe,

The cake will end up crazy.

If you do the cooking by the book.

Then you'll have a cake.”

Using the same phrase, and the same illustration, LazyTown is teaching an exactly opposite moral.

Perhaps the reason for this is that the creator of LazyTown is a gymnastics champion. He would know that you don't win medals by doing things your own way. Also, when it comes to back-flips and aerials, do it your own way and possibly kill yourself.

I found the contrast amusing and it got me thinking. It made me realize that it is important to teach children to do things by the book.

Especially the Book.

Cause if the way is hazy, there's always Proverbs 3:1, 2

“My son, do not forget my law,

But let your heart keep my commands;

For length of days and long life

And peace they will add to you.”


Wow.

Leela's picture

That's a cool observation, Aisling.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Call 1-800-555-1234 for questions, comments, or snotty remarks.


Yep

Quartz's picture

Very true… :-J It’s amusing that two children’s shows on possibly the same network teach exactly oposite things, to be sure. *lol* What are the poor kids supposed to draw from that? No wonder people grow up so backward…

-------

“… But as for me, I trust in [God.]” –Psalm 55:23


Hmm...

Lilly's picture

At first I thought maybe you were taking the first clip too seriously but then I watched it. Even though they said "It's good to do things the proper way" they made it seem like wanting to do things "by the book" makes you a stiff victorian and even made it seem bad to be that way. The Lazy Town song makes much more sense, if you put a ham into a cake then you're gonna end up with one crazy cake.

---------------

Fopsworth doesn't exist, he's really Aisling.


Score

Quartz's picture

Very good observation about the Wow Wow Wubzy song, Lilly! :)

-------

“… But as for me, I trust in [God.]” –Psalm 55:23


The Snag

Quartz's picture

Of course, there’s one thing that makes this a little more confusing. Let’s say you’re out spending time with a friend, and expect things to go a certain way. When they don’t necessarily, it can be a little frustrating, but you often just need to loosen up a little bit.

In that case the phrase, “It doesn’t have to be by the book,” actually could be good advice.

I think the difference is whether it’s your book or the book of an authority in your life.

-------

“… But as for me, I trust in [God.]” –Psalm 55:23


My observations

Mariel 7's picture

I think that in the comparison of the two episodes, I think you also need to take into account the quality of the shows as a whole. From what I've seen/heard about the two shows, it seems to me that Lazy Town is actually a good show which teaches children things about morals and reality at the same time. Wow Wow Wubzy seems like all it does is entertain small children and teach them absolutely nothing.

So yeah. I totally agree ^.^

---------------

Learn to laugh at yourself, and you shall never cease to be entertained.

~An Irish comedian whose name escapes me~


Good points

SangMing's picture

I have to agree with you, Ais, 100%. It's VERY important to do the right thing. And there are many, many cases where the results of doing things the wrong way could be disastrous. Cooking, building anything, and any activities involving traffic come to mind.

I liked Lilly's observation:Even though they said "It's good to do things the proper way" they made it seem like wanting to do things "by the book" makes you a stiff victorian and even made it seem bad to be that way. I noticed this myself and it's been a running theme is society for a very long time now. The goal seems to be to laugh at and make fun of anyone who wants to do things in the accepted ways. Or do the accepted things! Some of the names they call us include, Victorians, Puritans, uptight, and (my personal favorite) anal.

Mariel said: Wow Wow Wubzy seems like all it does is entertain small children and teach them absolutely nothing. If only that was possible! It's been my experience that it isn't possible to teach kids nothing. They're little learning and imitating machines that never stop! They will learn from you, it's always a question of what.

---------------

I get up, I walk, I fall down. Meanwhile, I keep dancing. - Hillel